The Unmanageable Society of Monolothist Humans
That crowds follow their own logics is one thing. That no one ought to teach or educate anyone is another — and perhaps the harder lesson to accept.
Human civilizations have always been systems of power as much as of culture. They organize life through habits, expectations, and rules that seem self-evident while shaping nearly everything we do. What we often call a “crisis” in society is not a sign of failure but a symptom of how these systems naturally operate: through competition, imitation, and the effort to preserve order even when that order no longer serves life.
Across history, one community has often defined itself against another — each convinced that it carried a more refined sense of morality or destiny. Yet beneath those conflicts, people shared a remarkably similar framework: the belief that to be human meant to belong to a single, dominant order — to speak one truth, to follow one pattern. We might call this human monolithism: the assumption that unity requires sameness.
It is not an evil trait, nor an individual fault. It is a habit of thought that developed as societies grew, a way to keep coherence among uncertain lives. But it has a cost. Within such a frame, sensitivity and care for the nonhuman world had little room to breathe. Nature and animals became the silent backdrop to human progress — and the more we achieved, the more we lost our sense of proportion within that larger field of life.
Today the effects are visible everywhere. The monolithic model is no longer sustainable, yet it still shapes how we talk about growth, rights, and even empathy. We cannot easily “educate” ourselves out of it, because it is woven into our language and our sense of what being human means.
Still, there are possibilities. Small, local, unassuming forms of resistance — gestures, communities, and thoughts that do not seek to dominate but to coexist. These are not heroic answers, but they are real. And perhaps they mark the beginning of a more patient kind of civilization — one that no longer fears the unmanageable, but learns to live with it.
—